Top 5 Most Trusted Novelty ID Sites in 2025 (With Real Reviews)

Looking for a safe, fun, and high-quality novelty ID? We’ve done the homework for you. Novelty IDs have exploded in popularity—not just as prank gifts, but as props for cosplay, parties, social content, and virtual team-building events. But here’s the catch: not all ID sites are created equal. Some are shady, some are overpriced, and others could put you at legal risk. That’s why we researched and reviewed the top 5 most trusted novelty ID websites in 2025, based on real customer feedback, shipping reliability, design quality, and overall experience. Whether you’re shopping for a hilarious gag gift or an eye-catching party accessory, our guide will help you find a vendor that’s safe, legit, and worth your money.

1. IDPapa Best Overall

IDPapa has earned the top spot for one clear reason: it does everything legally, professionally, and creatively. Every ID is marked as novelty only, but it looks and feels impressively real. That careful balance between realism and legality makes IDPapa stand out in a crowded market. It’s the go-to for people who want fun, personalized ID cards for gifts, jokes, parties, and content creation—without stepping over any legal lines. The designs are crisp, the layouts mimic popular state and country templates, and the overall presentation is top-notch for novelty purposes.

 ✅ Scannable-style templates (California, New York, Canada, etc.)

 ✅ Custom photo, name, title, and job field

 ✅ Fast worldwide shipping with tracking

 ✅ Clear legal boundaries: NO fake claims, just fun

IDPapa’s commitment to transparency and customer satisfaction makes it a favorite among content creators, event planners, and anyone looking to add a touch of comedy to their next gathering. Whether you want a license that says “Official Pizza Inspector” or a badge for your next team-building Zoom call, IDPapa makes the process smooth, safe, and surprisingly professional.

 Real Review:

“I’ve bought from IDPapa twice, once for a team-building event and once for a birthday gag. Both times, the quality was amazing, and it arrived faster than expected!” – Taylor L.

Best For: Social media creators, party planners, office pranks, TikTok skits, and safe gifting

2. FakeNewID.com — Most Custom Options

FakeNewID allows you to create novelty-style IDs with extensive customization options. They offer funny licenses, badges, and joke cards that resemble real IDs but are clearly marked as fake. What sets them apart is the sheer variety and creative freedom they offer users. Whether you're designing something outrageous for a bachelor party or a silly badge for your pet, you can tweak nearly every element to fit your exact vision. The interface is user-friendly, and the final product delivers solid quality with clear printing and durable materials.

✅ Wide variety of templates (fantasy, joke, parody IDs)

✅ Choose from dozens of fonts and colors

✅ Creative titles like “Zombie Hunter” or “CEO of Snacks”

This site is ideal for people who love the DIY experience and want to create something highly specific. You can get as quirky or as polished as you like, and their themed designs cover just about every occasion imaginable. With FakeNewID, the focus is on fun and flexibility, making it a go-to for party organizers, gamers, cosplay fans, and novelty gift lovers alike.

 Real Review:

“Great for bachelor party props and fun team cards. Wish the shipping was a bit faster, but the final product was worth it.” – Alex G.

Best For: Gag gifts, cosplay, themed events, party bundles

3. TheNoveltyIDShop.com — Best for Fast Delivery in the U.S.

This U.S.-based site specializes in quick novelty ID Blogs production for birthday gifts, family jokes, and more. It’s perfect for those last-minute shoppers who need something fun and lighthearted without the long wait times. While the design range is more basic than IDPapa, they make up for it with speed and simplicity. Their site is streamlined, easy to navigate, and perfect for people who just want a quick laugh without spending too much time customizing.

✅ Fast turnaround time (1–3 days for U.S. orders)

✅ Pre-set joke templates like “World’s Best Dad”

✅ Simple ordering process

If you're ordering from within the United States, TheNoveltyIDShop.com is a reliable option to get your novelty ID quickly and without hassle. Their pre-set joke templates take the guesswork out of the process, making it easy for people who may not want to design their own card from scratch. Whether you're prepping for a themed party, celebrating a quirky milestone, or just want to surprise a friend, this shop offers a straightforward solution that gets to your doorstep fast.

 Real Review:

“I ordered a novelty retirement ID for my boss and it got here just in time. Quality was decent, and it got a big laugh at the party.” – Marisa T.

Best For: Last-minute gifts, corporate fun, simple joke IDs

4. PrankID.com — Most Fun for Teens & College Students

This site leans heavily into the humor and novelty side of fake IDs. It’s not trying to mimic real licenses—instead, it celebrates the absurd. You won’t find realistic designs here—just silly cards made to spark laughs. From outrageous job titles to neon-colored templates, everything about PrankID.com screams parody. It’s the perfect destination for those who want to keep things light, loud, and laugh-out-loud funny.

✅ Totally exaggerated designs (no intent to deceive)

✅ Great for TikTok trends and viral skits

✅ Safe for younger users

What makes this site stand out is how well it taps into internet culture and Gen Z humor. Titles like "Intergalactic Pizza Inspector" or "Certified Meme Analyst" are tailor-made for social content, making these IDs ideal for TikTok, Instagram Reels, or YouTube shorts. The platform even encourages creativity by offering suggestions based on trending jokes and memes. It’s built for going viral, not blending in.

These novelty cards are also a safe option for younger users, such as teens and college students who want to be part of the fun without any legal gray areas. Because the designs are so exaggerated, there’s no confusion about their intent—they’re purely for entertainment. Whether you're giving one as a goofy gift or starring it in your next skit, PrankID.com ensures the experience stays fun, playful, and completely risk-free.

 Real Review:

“My friends and I used these IDs in a TikTok skit that got 80K views. They’re super fake-looking but that’s the point!” – Jayden M.

Best For: Teens, college humor, TikTok creators

5. NoveltyCardMaker.co — Most Budget-Friendly

If you're on a tight budget and want something super simple, this site offers affordable novelty cards that get the job done without breaking the bank. While it may not have the polish or creative flair of some of the higher-end sites, NoveltyCardMaker.co is perfect for quick, lighthearted gifts or party props when cost is the top priority. It’s a go-to for budget-conscious shoppers who still want to bring a smile to someone’s face.

✅ Cheapest on the list

✅ Customizable joke licenses

✅ Basic templates

The print quality and delivery speed vary depending on your location and order type, so it’s best to plan ahead if you're working on a deadline. That said, many users have noted that for the price, the quality is fair—and the customization options, while limited, are enough to personalize your card with a funny name, job title, or inside joke. This site is best suited for casual use and low-stakes occasions like gag gifts, stocking stuffers, or group games. If you're not overly concerned with premium finishes or ultra-fast delivery, NoveltyCardMaker.co gives you solid value for money.

 Real Review:

“It’s not the best-looking card, but for $9 it did the job. Got a few laughs and made a cute desk decoration.” – Emily R.

Best For: Budget gifts, desk jokes, novelty collections

Final Verdict: Go With IDPapa for the Best Overall Experience

While each site has its place, IDPapa Review stands out for combining realistic design, fast delivery, full customization, and total legal clarity. Whether you need a hilarious party prop or a TikTok-friendly character badge, IDPapa delivers every time—no stress, no risk.

Want a novelty ID you can show off?

 Go to  IDPapa.org and start customizing yours today.